Diversity, Fiction, Loved-it, Magical realism, NetGalley, Well known books, Women's

This Just In: Magical Alice Hoffman Still Writes Magically Or, Review of The Rules of Magic

The Rules of Magic (Practical Magic 0)

Check out on Goodreads
Get at Book Depository
★★★★✬  4.5 stars

You might have been able to tell from my headline that I really love Alice Hoffman’s writing. I started this year by reading Faithful and was insta-fanned right away (Yes, I just invented that word.) I also read Practical Magic in preparation for reading The Rules of Magic, and although I could feel it was written a while ago and wasn’t quite the same vibe, my love for Hoffman’s amazing prose only grew.

The topic matter? I believe we don’t have the need for me to sum it up here, do we? Most of you will have heard of the book and probably seen the movie. I love this story in either of its forms. Witches, jinxes, family history, mystery… It’s all so delicious. Just the kind of topics I like. In this book though, we follow the lives of the Owens’ family before the heroines of Practical Magic are born, and what’s interesting – this time it’s not only the girls! We have a male Owens to read about, and he’s a great character. If you’ve read the first book, you will be pleasantly surprised not only to learn more about the family history, the town’s history or their traditions, but to actually find out more about the story of Sally and Gillian – the girls from Practical Magic.

Those who know the struggle of the Owens’ family – to never find love, and if they do, to lose it the worst way imaginable, will not be surprised by the fact that this is the main theme here as well. However, it’s not a book of love stories. As many of Hoffman’s books, The Rules of Magic talks more about finding oneself, about forgiving oneself, about facing one’s demons and one’s true identity. Identity is questioned a lot, and I was surprised to find that it’s not only questioned traditionally. I don’t want to include spoilers, but let’s just say that this book is more diverse than I expected.

Another great thing about The Rules of Magic and the main reason why I liked it more than Practical Magic was that it didn’t have the ‘beauty wins love’ vibe that I didn’t like about the first book. In Rules of Magic, you deserve love whether you’re pretty or just plain. Everyone deserves love. And what’s more, they deserve the kind of love they want. And they must fight for their love, because only something worth fighting for is true, and it can’t come easy. There is also no insta-lovey fated love anymore – in this book, love is just what it is – the connection of souls, something more undying than everything else. I hope Hoffman doesn’t mind me judging her through her writing like that, and I do believe it’s probably not my place – but for what it’s worth, I would dare to say that I can sense the maturity in this book, the change in how she herself saw the world then and now. It’s amazing to see this change of the world she wanted to build for those characters and these ones. It’s like a living book.

Ultimately, Alice Hoffman ponders: is being fated to lose everyone you love the Owens’ curse, or is it just being human? What if it is just another inevitability of life, just as how it ends when your time comes and you lose your own self? Mix that with a few potions, a few sprigs of lavender, a few animal familiars, and you’ve got a recipe for a great book. So it’s not really big news that Alice Hoffman still writes magically, but I’ll say it anyway.

I thank Alice Hoffman and Simon & Schuster for giving me a copy of the book in exchange for my honest opinion.

Have you read anything by Alice Hoffman? And do you like reading about witches, the different and the mysterious?

0 0 vote
Article Rating
Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Rosie Amber
3 years ago

I shall have to find tine to dabble in this series. Your enthusiasm for it leads the way.

3 years ago

Alice Hoffman is one of my all time favourite writers. I’m so excited to read this book and pleased you enjoyed it.

Sim @ Flipping Thru the Pages

I haven’t read anything by Alice Hoffman yet But reading your review made me want to read it

3 years ago

Beautiful post, Evelina! I re-discovered Hoffman after reading ”Faithfull (I wasn’t too impressed with ”Practical Magic”, I confess) and now I am eagerly waiting for ”The Rules of Magic”. Plus, I have the majority of her works on my list:)

Brian Joseph
3 years ago

I liked the movie. I thought that it was fun. I have not read the book. It sounds good.

Finding one’s identity shall forever fascinating writers and readers of ever genre out there.

Jennifer | Book Den
3 years ago

I’m so glad you enjoyed it! I saw the library list for this one today… it will be a while before it’s my turn.

Laura Thomas
3 years ago

I loved Practical Magic. Didn’t realize the story continued. Now I have to have this book!

Laura Thomas
3 years ago

Yeah, I meant to say prequel. LOL I added it to my wish list:)

3 years ago

I love the Practical Magic movie but didn’t think much of the book I’m afraid 🙁 her writing was excellent though and I’ve been wanting to check something else of hers out, is there anything you’d recommend?

Jan @ Notes from a Readerholic

Great review, Evelina. I haven’t read anything by Alice Hoffman, but have thought this book sounds very good. I’ll also have to check out Faithful.

Lashaan Balasingam
3 years ago

I’ve seen this author around and was pretty much convinced that there’s a solid fanbase behind her books. I definitely enjoyed reading your review as it highlighted her strengths and I’m really fascinated by how many different themes/ideas are explored in this one book alone. Fantastic review! 🙂

Olivia Roach
3 years ago

I actually hadn’t heard about this book before? And it’s going to be a movie? What planet have I even been on O.o Anyway, this was a brilliant review and you totally have me convinced that this is one worth me reading. I especially like the sound of all the themes it covers, about identity and finding yourself. I think a lot of people (me included) will really be able to relate to those messages.

Dragonfly @ Our Familiarium
Dragonfly @ Our Familiarium
3 years ago

ok so I added this one too among MANY! It seem you will be perpetually featured in my PPP!!! LOL

Karen Blue
3 years ago

For the record, I have read this post at least twice. I am sure it was on my phone at work and so I just starred it and meant to some back later and comment. Sorry it took me a few days (here I am…tada!).
I am so glad to see you enjoyed this book as much as I did. I did like meeting the male Owen character, I was sure there would only be females in this book. Thanks for sharing your honest thoughts!

Tammy @ Books, Bones & Buffy

I loved this too, but I don’t think I’ve ever met an Alice Hoffman book I didn’t love